Last week we got a gift in the mail -- a selection of 6 different wines from MyWinesDirect. They are a website where you can order wines for yourself or others, and - get this - there's always free shipping. We decided to review their wines and their service the only way we know how - with a bunch of friends and some food.
We had eight friends swing by the office last week, with promises of wine and pizza from North Beach Pizza (maybe not the most elegant, but who doesn't love pizza and wine) and a winetasting party. And they came willingly. Shocking. They were a mixture of wine lovers who shop for wine all the time, and others who enjoy just picking up a bottle now and then. We disguised all six wines with our colorful WineWrappers from WineParty (which was recently featured in the Washington Post and Gayot !). And the tasting and talking began.
Our friends Justin (from BPS who also happens to hook us up with all our local printing needs, and we need a lot) and his wife Aya regularly get a selection of six wines from a local store but Justin said "I never had them all together before" -- this seemed to strike a bunch of people as a fun idea. Instead of holding on to the wines or enjoying them slowly one at a time, invite friends over and make it an event in itself to taste them all at once. And a box like we got from MyWinesDirect, does all the shopping for you, which might be great if you're too busy or just want to be surprised.
We started with a Chateau de la Roche Sauvignon Blanc 2003, from Touraine, this was quite a light wine, almost too light without much of a nose. It got in the 3-5 zone in the rankings (with 1 being great and 5 not great). Next up, we had Hahn Estates Chardonnay 2002 from Monterey CA. This was buttery, smooth, fuller-bodied, with some nuttiness. It generally rated around a 2-3. Neither white was a huge crowd pleaser, but the fun began with the reds.
The group split on their favorites between the 3rd and 4th wines -- a good argument for having a wide variety of wines on your table. The Moorewood Pinot Noir 2001 was a hit with some people (especially Chip and me) -- great with pizza, smooth light with berry flavors, great body, really lovely and woody with some strawberries. Others in the group were big fans of our fourth wine, the Palio Vecchio Merlot 2000. This Napa Valley wine was described as musky, peppery, bittersweet chocolate, earthy, nice tannins. And some people wanted more of that right away.
The final two wines were a Chateau Picoron Bordeaux - Cote de Castillon 2000 and a Vitae Sangiovese 2001 from Puglia, Italy. The Bordeaux got comments like "Yum, great structure, with licorice notes, new wood, barnyardy - in a good way." Though one person described it as having a bigger bark than bite, and too watery. The final wine was almost port-like in its lovely sweetness, but without being syrupy. People were surprised by it and most enjoyed it. Perhaps a good sign of how much people enjoyed trying all these wines is that the 4 reds were polished off by the end of the night.
So, what did our wine lovers think of the idea of giving or getting MyWinesDirect? They loved the free shipping and that each box comes with their tasting notes, as well as note sheets where you can take your own notes. They also really liked the suggestions of what kinds of foods to serve with each wine. The price was also popular - $79.95 for all six wines. The individual wine prices, if you were to buy them through MyWinesDirect, seemed a little expensive and not quite such a deal as the group, but not bad. And the group in general said the imagery used in the marketing worked better for gifts for people with more traditional tastes, who are a little less urban.
Our favorite comment came from Justin -- "It's like speed dating for wines" - now that's the kind of dating I like. Chip said the drawback for him on a service like this is that he really wants to know who he's talking to - like he can at a winery he loves or a local wine store. But for others they liked the wide variety that they never would have picked themselves and MyWinesDirect offers a variety that you can't get when you join one winery. The service seems great if you live in a city that doesn't have great wine stores, than for people who live in a place like SF. It also seems like the quality is good across the board - not every wines was a favorite for everyone, but each person discovered something new they liked and wanted more of. Tune in for our next tasting....
